Does Personal Injury Compensation Cover Wheelchair Access and Other Home Modifications?

Share on Facebook
Share on X
Share on LinkedIn
By Bill Wells
Board-Certified Personal Injury Attorney
If a wheelchair now keeps you from getting through your front door, the fix can be part of your claim. One Texas appeals court called adapting an existing home a plausible medical expense but rejected paying for a new house.

In Texas, it can. When someone else’s negligence causes an injury that changes how you get around your home, your claim can include the cost of ramps, wider doorways, an accessible bathroom, and similar changes. The evidence must tie each change to the injury and show what it will reasonably cost. A Texas appeals court has said that paying to make an existing home accessible would be a plausible future medical expense. As a Galveston County personal injury attorney, Bill T. Wells, Of Counsel to The Payne Law Group, helps seriously injured people in League City build that proof.

How Texas Law Treats the Cost of Changing Your Home

Texas damages law defines economic damages as payment for actual economic or financial loss. It also defines future damages as losses incurred after the date of the court’s judgment. The cost of wheelchair changes still needed after the judgment fits both descriptions. Texas law also requires the jury, or the judge in a trial without a jury, to set economic damages separately from pain, impairment, and other losses that come without a bill.

A Texas appeals court has analyzed accessibility costs as future medical expenses, which are the costs of care an injured person will need after trial. To recover them, you have to show a reasonable probability that the expense will happen and what it will reasonably cost. Texas courts do not require precise evidence. The jury can base the award on the nature of the injury, the care you received before trial, and your condition at the time of trial.

In a 2009 case, the Eastland Court of Appeals said that if a doctor identified changes needed to make an injured person’s existing home accessible, recovering the cost of those changes would be plausible. In 2023, the Corpus Christi-Edinburg Court of Appeals read that decision as saying such costs would likely be recoverable.

Which Home Modifications May Be Included in a Personal Injury Claim?

Which changes you need depends on your injury and your house. After a catastrophic injury, a person with a spinal cord injury who uses a wheelchair every day needs different changes than a person with a brain injury who struggles with balance. Common examples include:

  • Entrances: A ramp, a zero-step entry, or a porch lift
  • Doorways and halls: Wider door frames and removed thresholds so a wheelchair can pass
  • Bathrooms: A roll-in shower, grab bars set in reinforced walls, and a sink with knee space
  • Stairs: A stairlift or a platform lift in a two-story home
  • Kitchens: Lowered counters and appliances with front controls

Each item needs a medical reason behind it. Tie every change to a task the injury keeps you from doing. When a change has no medical reason, it looks like a remodel, and the insurance company can argue against paying for it.

How Do You Prove That Home Modifications Are Necessary?

The doctors who treat you supply the first proof. Their records describe what you can and cannot do and whether those limits are permanent. An occupational therapist, a clinician who helps people manage daily tasks after an injury, or another rehabilitation specialist can then visit your home and match your limits to specific barriers, such as a bathroom door too narrow for your chair.

The injured people in both Texas cases discussed above used a life care plan. A life care planner who testified in a Texas case described it as an assessment after an injury “to determine future health and medical care needs and the cost of those items.” Local contractors then price each change at your address.

In Parks v. Migl, a 2023 Texas appeals decision reviewing a Cameron County jury verdict, the injured woman proved her future care costs with a life care plan, though her case involved in-home help rather than home modifications. A certified nurse life care planner listed the injured woman’s future needs, and a second expert calculated their present value, which is the lump sum today that covers costs spread over future years. The appeals court upheld the jury’s $701,744 award for future medical expenses, which included paid help with cooking, cleaning, and errands. Most of that award paid for in-home help. A claim for home changes relies on the same kinds of experts.

How Are the Future Costs of Home Modifications Calculated?

Ramps, lifts, and automatic door openers need repairs, and they wear out. A life care plan for someone injured young can run for decades, so the plan should list each item, how often it must be serviced or replaced, and the cost each time. An economist then converts that stream of future costs into present value.

The jury sets the number. If the evidence does not support it, an appeals court can give the injured person a choice between accepting a lower amount and going through a new trial. Texas law gives the jury discretion to award an amount within the range of the evidence, so a detailed plan with current local prices gives jurors a figure they can rely on. With a vague estimate, the insurance company can argue for the low end of the range.

Why a New House Is Harder to Recover Than a Ramp

A 2009 Texas appeals decision matters most if your current home cannot be adapted. In Matbon, Inc. v. Gries, a couple badly hurt in a 2005 head-on collision presented a life care plan that included moving from Colorado Springs to San Antonio and building a 4,000-square-foot wheelchair-accessible house.

The Eastland court held that the trial court should not have allowed evidence of those costs as future medical expenses. The court gave three reasons. A new home involves personal tastes in housing. The estimate did not subtract the value of the couple’s current home.

On those facts, paying to relocate and build a new house went beyond the purpose of injury damages, which is to make the injured person whole. The court also rejected the cost of a financial advisor and conditioned its approval of the husband’s future medical award on reducing it from $500,000 to $325,000. That $325,000 was more than the roughly $295,560 in other future care costs, and the court pointed in part to the doctor’s testimony that the couple’s existing home would need modifications.

Price the changes your current home needs first. Because Matbon faulted the estimate for not subtracting the value of the couple’s current home, any request for a new home should show why the current one cannot be adapted and account for its value.

What if Your Accessibility Needs Change Over Time?

Needs change as the years pass. A person who can move from a wheelchair to a bed using arm strength today may need a ceiling lift years from now. Because the jury looks at your condition at the time of trial, your doctors and life care planner should address the changes they expect over your lifetime as well as the ones you need now.

Watch the filing deadline too. For most personal injury claims, Texas sets a deadline of two years after the day the claim arises to file a lawsuit. Build the long-term plan before you sign a settlement release or agree to any number. The insurance company will usually ask you to sign a release promising not to file more claims for the accident. After that, you generally cannot go back for more money if your needs grow.

How Bill T. Wells Can Help

Bill T. Wells has handled serious injury and wrongful death cases for over 30 years and has been Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law since 1990. Bill is Of Counsel to The Payne Law Group and owns and leads its Galveston County office in League City. He has made more than 500 appearances in Galveston County courts.

Insurance companies move quickly to protect their interests, and Bill knows how to push back. He can work with your doctors, therapists, life care planners, and economists to establish the full cost of the care and home changes your injury requires.

When you call, you will first speak with our team in Bryan. From that point on, Bill handles your case personally. The initial consultation is free, and our phones are answered 24 hours a day. Se Habla Español. Contact us today to get started.

About the Author
Bill Wells has been Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization since 1990. The Board of Legal Specialization was created by the Supreme Court of Texas and is charged with recognizing lawyers that have demonstrated special competence in a particular field of law, such as personal injury and wrongful death.
By Bill Wells
Board-Certified Personal Injury Attorney
Does Personal Injury Compensation Cover Wheelchair Access and Other Home Modifications?
If a wheelchair now keeps you from getting through your front door, the fix can be part of your claim. One Texas appeals court called adapting an existing home a plausible medical expense but rejected paying for a new house.

In Texas, it can. When someone else’s negligence causes an injury that changes how you get around your home, your claim can include the cost of ramps, wider doorways, an accessible bathroom, and similar changes. The evidence must tie each change to the injury and show what it will reasonably cost. A Texas appeals court has said that paying to make an existing home accessible would be a plausible future medical expense. As a Galveston County personal injury attorney, Bill T. Wells, Of Counsel to The Payne Law Group, helps seriously injured people in League City build that proof.

How Texas Law Treats the Cost of Changing Your Home

Texas damages law defines economic damages as payment for actual economic or financial loss. It also defines future damages as losses incurred after the date of the court’s judgment. The cost of wheelchair changes still needed after the judgment fits both descriptions. Texas law also requires the jury, or the judge in a trial without a jury, to set economic damages separately from pain, impairment, and other losses that come without a bill.

A Texas appeals court has analyzed accessibility costs as future medical expenses, which are the costs of care an injured person will need after trial. To recover them, you have to show a reasonable probability that the expense will happen and what it will reasonably cost. Texas courts do not require precise evidence. The jury can base the award on the nature of the injury, the care you received before trial, and your condition at the time of trial.

In a 2009 case, the Eastland Court of Appeals said that if a doctor identified changes needed to make an injured person’s existing home accessible, recovering the cost of those changes would be plausible. In 2023, the Corpus Christi-Edinburg Court of Appeals read that decision as saying such costs would likely be recoverable.

Which Home Modifications May Be Included in a Personal Injury Claim?

Which changes you need depends on your injury and your house. After a catastrophic injury, a person with a spinal cord injury who uses a wheelchair every day needs different changes than a person with a brain injury who struggles with balance. Common examples include:

  • Entrances: A ramp, a zero-step entry, or a porch lift
  • Doorways and halls: Wider door frames and removed thresholds so a wheelchair can pass
  • Bathrooms: A roll-in shower, grab bars set in reinforced walls, and a sink with knee space
  • Stairs: A stairlift or a platform lift in a two-story home
  • Kitchens: Lowered counters and appliances with front controls

Each item needs a medical reason behind it. Tie every change to a task the injury keeps you from doing. When a change has no medical reason, it looks like a remodel, and the insurance company can argue against paying for it.

How Do You Prove That Home Modifications Are Necessary?

The doctors who treat you supply the first proof. Their records describe what you can and cannot do and whether those limits are permanent. An occupational therapist, a clinician who helps people manage daily tasks after an injury, or another rehabilitation specialist can then visit your home and match your limits to specific barriers, such as a bathroom door too narrow for your chair.

The injured people in both Texas cases discussed above used a life care plan. A life care planner who testified in a Texas case described it as an assessment after an injury “to determine future health and medical care needs and the cost of those items.” Local contractors then price each change at your address.

In Parks v. Migl, a 2023 Texas appeals decision reviewing a Cameron County jury verdict, the injured woman proved her future care costs with a life care plan, though her case involved in-home help rather than home modifications. A certified nurse life care planner listed the injured woman’s future needs, and a second expert calculated their present value, which is the lump sum today that covers costs spread over future years. The appeals court upheld the jury’s $701,744 award for future medical expenses, which included paid help with cooking, cleaning, and errands. Most of that award paid for in-home help. A claim for home changes relies on the same kinds of experts.

How Are the Future Costs of Home Modifications Calculated?

Ramps, lifts, and automatic door openers need repairs, and they wear out. A life care plan for someone injured young can run for decades, so the plan should list each item, how often it must be serviced or replaced, and the cost each time. An economist then converts that stream of future costs into present value.

The jury sets the number. If the evidence does not support it, an appeals court can give the injured person a choice between accepting a lower amount and going through a new trial. Texas law gives the jury discretion to award an amount within the range of the evidence, so a detailed plan with current local prices gives jurors a figure they can rely on. With a vague estimate, the insurance company can argue for the low end of the range.

Why a New House Is Harder to Recover Than a Ramp

A 2009 Texas appeals decision matters most if your current home cannot be adapted. In Matbon, Inc. v. Gries, a couple badly hurt in a 2005 head-on collision presented a life care plan that included moving from Colorado Springs to San Antonio and building a 4,000-square-foot wheelchair-accessible house.

The Eastland court held that the trial court should not have allowed evidence of those costs as future medical expenses. The court gave three reasons. A new home involves personal tastes in housing. The estimate did not subtract the value of the couple’s current home.

On those facts, paying to relocate and build a new house went beyond the purpose of injury damages, which is to make the injured person whole. The court also rejected the cost of a financial advisor and conditioned its approval of the husband’s future medical award on reducing it from $500,000 to $325,000. That $325,000 was more than the roughly $295,560 in other future care costs, and the court pointed in part to the doctor’s testimony that the couple’s existing home would need modifications.

Price the changes your current home needs first. Because Matbon faulted the estimate for not subtracting the value of the couple’s current home, any request for a new home should show why the current one cannot be adapted and account for its value.

What if Your Accessibility Needs Change Over Time?

Needs change as the years pass. A person who can move from a wheelchair to a bed using arm strength today may need a ceiling lift years from now. Because the jury looks at your condition at the time of trial, your doctors and life care planner should address the changes they expect over your lifetime as well as the ones you need now.

Watch the filing deadline too. For most personal injury claims, Texas sets a deadline of two years after the day the claim arises to file a lawsuit. Build the long-term plan before you sign a settlement release or agree to any number. The insurance company will usually ask you to sign a release promising not to file more claims for the accident. After that, you generally cannot go back for more money if your needs grow.

How Bill T. Wells Can Help

Bill T. Wells has handled serious injury and wrongful death cases for over 30 years and has been Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law since 1990. Bill is Of Counsel to The Payne Law Group and owns and leads its Galveston County office in League City. He has made more than 500 appearances in Galveston County courts.

Insurance companies move quickly to protect their interests, and Bill knows how to push back. He can work with your doctors, therapists, life care planners, and economists to establish the full cost of the care and home changes your injury requires.

When you call, you will first speak with our team in Bryan. From that point on, Bill handles your case personally. The initial consultation is free, and our phones are answered 24 hours a day. Se Habla Español. Contact us today to get started.

About the Author
Bill Wells has been Board Certified in Personal Injury Trial Law by the Texas Board of Legal Specialization since 1990. The Board of Legal Specialization was created by the Supreme Court of Texas and is charged with recognizing lawyers that have demonstrated special competence in a particular field of law, such as personal injury and wrongful death.
Attorney Advertising
Website developed in accordance with Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.2.
If you encounter any issues while using this site, please contact us: 713.819.2648